Thursday, May 13, 2010

Home EKG Monitor? YIKES.

From Hammacher Schlemmer* Catalogue:

Cleared by the FDA, this is the handheld cordless device that lets you monitor your heart's rhythm without requiring a trip to the doctor's office.  The monitor uses four integrated sensors--not uncomfortable electrode cables--that provide an instantaneous EKG reading simply by holding the unit in one hand and pressing it against the palm of your other hand. It displays an accurate EKG and heart rate on its 1 3/4" x 2 3/4" monochrome screen, along with an easy-to-interpret emoticon that indicates a normal or irregular heartbeat. The lightweight, portable unit can monitor multiple users and its internal memory stores up to 200 30-second data records. Data may be uploaded to a PC using the USB cable provided, and the included software for Windows 7 and Vista maintains a record of your heart's health over time. Two AAA batteries (included) provide up to 400 readings. Includes storage pouch. 5 1/2" L x 3 1/2" W x 3/4" H (4 oz.)
Item 78657 $199.95

Does anyone else see how many levels of wrong this is? I talk to people every day panicked because they are having trouble with the thermometers and BP machines they are using - never mind adding an EKG monitor, which, last I checked - is difficult for an untrained RN to read, never mind your average JQPublic. I can only imagine the level of hysteria a home EKG machine will beget.

Does it come with instructions how to differentiate between artifact and a real problem?   The EMS is going to love those calls for misinterpreted MI's. 

Don't get me wrong - I am all for a patient taking charge of their health and finding out as much as they can about what is going on with their bodies and all.....but an EKG as a tool for the layman to judge whether to delay care or not is sketchy at best - never mind potentially dangerous.

And what is with the emoticons? So now the smiley/frowny faces of the pain scale is moving to the EKG machine?

Hopefully there won't be a market for these for the general public.

Here is another one:
At least this one comes with a warning that states: " The unit is not the monitor used in clinical institution or hospital, but is used for spot-check purpose ONLY.  The measurement results are useful for doctor, but do not make direct diagnostic or analytical decision based on the information by this unit."

Then it goes on to provide a little chart:

...........and gives examples of circumstances that might make your heart behave differently ..........but then goes on to say:
"Suggestion: If it belongs to a pathology condition, please go to hospital"
Hopefully the average layperson using this will be able to tell the difference.  ( frowny-face emoticon placed here)

Ok.....upon reading the PDF instruction manual, the grammatical construction  is such that it is sometimes difficult to figure out the what is being said.

Hopefully the construction of the machine is not done in the same haphazard way.















*Hammacher Schlemmer has since stopped selling these.

No comments: